Hellbound Hearts

hellboundhearts.com

Insidious: Out of the Further Found the Nerve I Didn't Know I Had

I don't scare easy. I've been let down by this franchise before. Then a PG-13 about a dental hygienist and three elderly strangers had me squirming next to my extremely unbothered daughter.

Allen Erwin·Hellbound Hearts·September 11, 2026·5 min read

I need to open this review with a confession, because reviews are honesty exercises and this one cost me something to learn.

I took my daughter to see Insidious: Out of the Further. I am the horror guy. I run a horror website. I do not, as a general rule, scare easy — I've been telling people for years that I don't really have the gene for it, that I watch this stuff with a mechanic's eye. And for the entire first half of this movie, I squirmed in my seat like a man in a dentist's waiting room while my kid sat next to me, serene, occasionally checking on me the way you'd check on a nervous dog during fireworks.

Somewhere in that first half I made a genuine discovery about myself, at my age, in a theater, in public: elderly people doing unsettling things and fingers going into mouths are apparently my thing. The bad kind of my thing. The squirm kind.

And here's what I respect: that was not an accident. This movie knows exactly which nerves it's playing. It found one of mine I didn't know I had.

Where I Was With This Franchise

Full disclosure on the scorecard, because context matters for a review. I have been hit and miss on Insidious from the start. When The Red Door came out in 2023 I was genuinely excited — franchise homecoming, Patrick Wilson directing — and I walked out let down. So when a sixth entry got dated, my expectations were somewhere around ankle height. A fifteen-year-old franchise, a new director, a new family, late-August release slot. You know the shape of the movie I was braced for. I bought tickets mostly because it's what we do.

I was wrong. This is the most surprised I've been by a franchise entry in a long while.

What It Is

Spoiler-light, because that's how we do reviews here. Out of the Further hands the series to a new family. Amelia Eve plays Gemma, a single mother — a dental hygienist, which the film weaponizes, and I'll say no more about that except to repeat that I have discovered things about myself — raising her daughter in the house she grew up in. The hook, and it's a real one: Gemma doesn't just slip into the Further, the franchise's purgatorial realm of lost souls. She can bring what lives there back out.

That's the reversal this series needed. Five movies have been built on the same directional dread — our world is the safe side, the Further is the place you must not get stuck. Flip the valve and suddenly the membrane leaks the other way. The safe side stops existing. It reframes the entire mythology without breaking it, which is the hardest trick in legacy horror, and the movie mostly pulls it off.

Jacob Chase directs — the Come Play guy — from a story he shares with David Leslie Johnson-McGoldrick, who wrote a couple of Conjurings. Lin Shaye is back as Elise, because there is no Insidious without Lin Shaye and the producers know it. Joseph Bishara, the franchise's composer since the first film, is still doing the thing where the score feels like it's happening behind you.

The PG-13 Argument

Here's the part I keep chewing on. This movie got under my skin harder than most R-rated horror this year, and it did it with a PG-13.

That rating gets treated like a confession of weakness in horror circles — like the movie is admitting up front that it won't go all the way. But Insidious has never had gore to lean on. This franchise has always had to win on pure craft: sound design, negative space, the shape of a figure standing where a figure should not be. And Out of the Further understands the oldest secret of the rating — there are doors into an audience that gore can't open. A mouth is one of them. You can violate a mouth on a PG-13 without spilling a drop of anything, and it lands harder than a gallon of the red stuff, because everyone in the theater has been in the chair, lips numb, someone else's fingers where your voice should be. Helplessness with fluoride. The elderly are another door — aging bodies, wrong smiles, the uncanny gap between frail and wrong — and this film walks through both doors like it owns the building.

There are doors into an audience that gore can't open. This movie found two of them, and one of mine I didn't know existed.

The first half is the stronger half — patient, mean, confident in its silences. The back stretch gets busier and more conventional as the mythology machinery takes over, which is the franchise's oldest habit and the reason this isn't a perfect movie. But the ratio of earned scares to jump-scare junk food is the best it's been in years.

Critics Said Mixed. The Crowd Said Otherwise.

The reviews came back lukewarm. Audiences did not care — the movie has pulled well north of a hundred million dollars on a budget under twenty, which in Blumhouse arithmetic is a triumph. I've written before about how horror gets graded on a curve that tilts against it, so read the split however you like. All I can tell you is what happened in my row: one lifelong horror guy doing the involuntary shoulder-scrunch for forty-five straight minutes, and one teenager entirely unbothered, enjoying the film and, I suspect, enjoying me more.

Verdict

Go see it. See it in a theater, with the sound doing what Bishara wants it to do. If you fell off this franchise — if The Red Door lost you like it nearly lost me — this is the entry that earns the way back. It's not flawless, the last act won't surprise franchise veterans, and your mileage on the mythology may vary.

But it found something new in a fifteen-year-old haunted house, it did it inside a PG-13, and it taught me at my age that I have a squirm button and where it is.

My daughter, for the record, remains unscared. Of the movie, anyway. She did have to sit next to me.

HELLBOUND HEARTS — hellboundhearts.com

◆